More unique IPs than any network on the planet, in the world's largest residential pool. That's Shifter.More unique IPs than any network, in the world's largest pool. That's Shifter.

See the numbers

Proxy alternatives

Find a better proxy alternative.

Pick the proxy provider you use today and see every measured residential network ranked against it, by overall score, cost per result, speed or success rate.

18 measured networks · updated 57 mins ago
Alternatives, ranked
Live
FleetProxy logo
Your providerFleetProxy
80.6
  1. 1 Shifter logo
    Shifter
    94.1+13.5 pts
  2. 2 Oxylabs logo
    Oxylabs
    83.4+2.8 pts
  3. 3 Decodo logo
    Decodo
    81.5+0.9 pts
  • No paid placement
  • Measured against yours
  • Shared pools flagged
  • Same rules for Shifter
01 · Providers

Which provider do you use today?

Pick the network you pay for now. Its page ranks every other measured network against it, on the same requests to the same targets.

  1. #1 Shifter logo Shifter Shifter alternatives 94.1 A+
  2. #2 Oxylabs logo Oxylabs Oxylabs alternatives 83.4 A
  3. #3 Decodo logo Decodo Decodo alternatives 81.5 A
  4. #4 FleetProxy logo FleetProxy FleetProxy alternatives 80.6 A
  5. #5 Geonode logo Geonode Geonode alternatives 80.3 A
  6. #6 DataImpulse logo DataImpulse DataImpulse alternatives 80.1 A
  7. #7 ProxyEmpire logo ProxyEmpire ProxyEmpire alternatives 79.9 B+
  8. #8 Webshare logo Webshare Webshare alternatives 79.3 B+
  9. #9 NodeMaven logo NodeMaven NodeMaven alternatives 77.7 B+
  10. #10 SOAX logo SOAX SOAX alternatives 77.5 B+
  11. #11 Proxy-Seller logo Proxy-Seller Proxy-Seller alternatives 77.2 B+
  12. #12 Byteful logo Byteful Byteful alternatives 75.6 B+
  13. #13 Infatica logo Infatica Infatica alternatives 74.6 B+
  14. #14 Massive logo Massive Massive alternatives 74.2 B+
  15. #15 Evomi logo Evomi Evomi alternatives 73.1 B+
  16. #16 Rayobyte logo Rayobyte Rayobyte alternatives 71.5 B
  17. #17 Proxy-Cheap logo Proxy-Cheap Proxy-Cheap alternatives 70.5 B
  18. #18 IPRoyal logo IPRoyal IPRoyal alternatives 66.4 B

Good Fair Weak

Next · 02 When to switch When is it worth looking elsewhere?
02 · When to switch

When to look for an alternative

Six signs that the network you use is costing you more than it should, and where each one shows up in Atlas.

  • Success rate keeps slipping

    More requests fail on the sites you run every day. Each failure is billed and has to be sent again.

    See the leaderboard
  • Pages take longer to load

    Latency adds up over thousands of requests. A slower network means longer jobs and more open connections.

    Compare latency
  • The bill grows, results do not

    When spend rises faster than delivered pages, look at the cost per successful result, not the price per GB.

    See the true cost
  • The same IPs, another seller

    Some networks resell one upstream pool. Switching between them can change the invoice and leave the IPs the same.

    See pool overlap
  • Blocked on the sites you need

    A network can be strong on easy sites and weak on search engines or marketplaces. Check success per target.

    See every target
  • Thin where you need coverage

    A large pool can still have few IPs in the countries and cities you work in. Look at unique IPs per country.

    Browse the networks
Next · 03 How we rank How are the alternatives ranked?
03 · How we rank

How alternatives are ranked

Four ways to order the same field, each from measured figures. No paid placement and no affiliate order.

  • 01

    Best overall

    Ordered by the Atlas Score: reliability, speed, coverage, pool quality and value, weighted into one number.

  • 02

    Lowest cost

    Ordered by what 1,000 successful requests cost, so failed requests and retries are counted in.

  • 03

    Fastest

    Ordered by median latency on the same requests, from the first byte sent to the full page back.

  • 04

    Most reliable

    Ordered by success score across every target, so a network that only does well on easy sites ranks lower.

Checklist

What to compare in a proxy alternative

Price and pool size are the two numbers every provider advertises, and the two that say least about whether a network will work for you. These six do.

Success rate on the sites you actually use

A single success rate hides more than it shows. Networks that pass nearly every request on easy pages can fall well short on search engines, marketplaces or AI assistants, which is where most scraping budgets go.

Compare alternatives on the target type you run, with retries counted, over at least a week. A short test on a quiet afternoon tells you very little about a busy Monday.

Cost per successful request, not price per GB

Residential plans are sold by the gigabyte, but a failed request still uses bandwidth and still bills. A network with a lower rate and a lower success rate can cost more for every page you actually receive.

Divide what you pay by what succeeds. If one request in five fails, every result takes 1.25 attempts, so the real rate is a quarter higher than the listed one.

Unique IPs you are given, not the pool on the website

Advertised pool sizes count every address a provider has ever seen. What matters is how many distinct IPs you are handed in a day, in the countries you target, because repeated addresses are what get flagged.

An alternative with a smaller headline number can hand out more fresh addresses than one with a larger claim.

How residential the pool really is

Some residential pools include addresses that belong to hosting companies rather than home internet providers. Websites treat those like datacenter traffic, so a higher share means more blocks on protected sites.

Check the share of datacenter ASNs and the overlap with other sellers before you switch, so the new pool is different from the one you are leaving.

Coverage in the countries and cities you need

Global totals do not tell you how deep a pool is in one market. Look at unique IPs per country, and per city if you target local results, then check that country, city and ASN targeting work the way your code expects.

How the IPs are sourced

Residential IPs should come from people who knowingly opt in and can opt out. Ask how consent is collected, whether customers are verified before they get access, and how abuse reports are handled.

Pools built from hidden SDKs or compromised devices carry legal and reputational risk, whatever the price.

Related reading: Proxy network alternatives: how to choose

Why teams look for a proxy alternative

Most teams start looking for a proxy alternative for one of three reasons, and all three are measurable before you switch. Measuring first is what separates a better network from a different invoice.

  • Requests start failing

    Targets that used to work return blocks and challenges. In Atlas it shows as a falling success rate on the same targets you run.

    Success by target
  • The bill outgrows the data

    Spend rises faster than the pages it delivers. In Atlas it shows as the cost per successful request, failures counted in.

    See the true cost
  • Countries a project needs are missing

    A new market needs IPs the network cannot supply. In Atlas it shows as unique IPs per country, not the advertised pool.

    Browse the networks

Switching rarely means rewriting code

Most residential networks use the same gateway format, a host and port with country or session settings in the username, so the work is in testing, not in integration.

Related reading: what to test in a proxy free trial

Residential, ISP or datacenter: which kind of alternative?

Sometimes the better alternative is a different kind of proxy rather than a different residential network. Atlas ranks rotating residential networks; this is how they compare with the other two kinds.

Rotating residential, ISP and datacenter proxies compared
Feature Rotating residentialISP (static residential)Datacenter
Where the IPs come from Home connectionsISP ranges in data centersCloud and hosting
How it is billed Per GBPer IPPer IP or per GB
Block resistance HighMedium to highLow
Speed Varies by exitFastFastest
Same IP for hours Sticky sessionsYesYes
Typical use Scraping, SERP, adsAccounts, checkoutOpen sites, volume

Related reading: Static or rotating residential proxies

How to switch proxy providers without downtime

Test the alternative on your own targets, confirm it is not reselling your current pool, price it per successful result, then move traffic in stages while the old provider is still running.

  1. 01

    Write down what you need

    List your targets, countries, session type, monthly volume and the success rate you need. This is what every alternative is measured against.

  2. 02

    Shortlist two or three networks

    Open your provider's page above and order the alternatives by what matters most to you: overall score, cost per result, speed or reliability.

  3. 03

    Trial on your own targets

    Run your real scripts through each trial at the same hours. Record success rate, latency and bandwidth per page, not just whether it connects.

  4. 04

    Check the pool and the bill

    Make sure the new pool is not the one you are leaving, then price the cost per successful result at your volume, with commitments and expiring gigabytes included.

  5. 05

    Move traffic in steps

    Send a slice of production traffic first. Keep the current provider until the new one holds up for a full billing cycle, then move the rest.

Can you trust a ranking of proxy alternatives?

Ordered by measurement, not commission

Many lists of proxy alternatives are ordered by affiliate commission. This one is ordered by measurement: every network is sent the same requests, to the same targets, on the same schedule, and scored by a published formula.

Shifter runs Atlas and is one of the networks in it. That is a conflict of interest, so it is handled in the open: Shifter is tested like everyone else, the method is public, and the dataset can be downloaded so anyone can recompute the ranking.

Read how every network is measured in the methodology, and how the conflict is handled in the disclosure.

  • No paid placement or affiliate order
  • Same requests and targets for every network
  • Shared pools flagged on every provider page
  • Shifter ranked by the same rules
FAQ

Frequently asked questions

Common questions about switching proxy providers and how the alternatives are ranked.

Pick the provider you use from the list on this page. Its alternatives page ranks every other measured network against it on the same requests to the same targets, and lets you order them by overall score, cost per result, speed or reliability.

By default, by the Atlas Score: reliability, speed, availability, coverage, IP diversity, datacenter exposure, pool authenticity and value, weighted into one number from 0 to 100. You can reorder the same list by the cost of 1,000 successful requests, by median latency or by success score.

No. There is no paid placement, no sponsored slot and no affiliate order. Every network is measured on the same schedule and ranked by the same published formula.

Not always. A failed request is still billed, so a network with a lower price per GB and a lower success rate can cost more per delivered page. Compare the cost per successful result for the targets you run.

Some networks resell the same upstream supply. When an alternative also holds 20% or more of your provider's IPs, its page flags it, because switching there may change the invoice without changing the IPs.

Shifter is tested on the same requests, targets and formula as every other network, and appears as an alternative only where its figures put it. The method and the dataset are public, so the ranking can be checked.

Usually, yes. Most residential networks use the same gateway format: a host and port, with the country, city or session set in the username. Switching means new credentials and checking that the targeting syntax matches, then testing on your own targets.

Run your real scripts against your real targets at the hours you normally work. Record the success rate with retries, median latency, bandwidth per page and how many distinct IPs you receive per country, and check that sticky sessions hold as long as advertised.

Hourly. The measurements behind every provider page run around the clock, the figures are updated hourly, and you can read them over the last 24 hours, 7 days or 30 days with the window picker at the bottom of the screen.

Get started

Thinking of switching? Test Shifter first

Run Shifter on your own targets with a 3-day money-back guarantee and check it against your current provider before you move any traffic.

3-day money-back guarantee. Cancel anytime.