More unique IPs than any network on the planet, in the world's largest residential pool. That's Shifter.More unique IPs than any network, in the world's largest pool. That's Shifter.

See the numbers

FleetProxy vs Shifter

FleetProxy vs Shifter: Proxy Comparison

Atlas put FleetProxy, used for market research and ad verification, and Shifter, used for web scraping and SEO monitoring, on the same requests; one is a city and ASN network, the other the first residential proxy network.

16 figures compared · updated 57 mins ago
FleetProxy vs Shifter
Live
FleetProxy logo FleetProxy vs Shifter logo Shifter
  1. 80.6 Atlas Score 94.1
  2. 6.8/10 Success 9.4/10
  3. 919 ms Latency p50 486 ms
  4. 7.15M Unique IPs 8.95M
  5. 216 Countries 221
  6. $9.07 $ / 1k successes $4.43
  • Same requests
  • Same targets
  • No paid placement
  • Gaps shown, never filled
01 · Verdict

Which should you pick, FleetProxy or Shifter?

Two Atlas Scores and a row count, for a buyer choosing between a network that puts ASN targeting first and one that puts targeting precision first.

FleetProxy leads on 1 16 figures compared Shifter leads on 15
FleetProxy logo

FleetProxy

#4
Atlas Score 80.6 A

Choose FleetProxy to

  • Collect profiles reliably
  • Pull more product listings
  • Clear JS challenges more often
Shifter logo

Shifter

#1
Atlas Score 94.1 A+

Choose Shifter to

  • Exclusive IPs
  • Lower price-monitoring costs
  • Track prices for less
Next · 02 Side by side How do they compare on every figure?
02 · Side by side

FleetProxy and Shifter side by side

Labels such as "ASN-targeting" and "three-pool" only go so far; this table gives every figure for FleetProxy and Shifter, each row's leader in green.

FleetProxy and Shifter compared on every measured figure
Metric
Verdict
Atlas Score 80.6 80.6 80.6 94.1 94.1 94.1
Rank #4 #4 #4 #1 #1 #1
Performance
Success 8.1/10 6.8/10 6.8/10 8.4/10 9.4/10 9.4/10
Latency p50 903 ms 919 ms 919 ms 531 ms 486 ms 486 ms
Challenge score 7.9/10 8.7/10 8.7/10 8.4/10 8.1/10 8.1/10
Requests 3.47M 12.0M 12.0M 5.35M 16.4M 16.4M
Availability 100.00% 99.82% 99.82% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00%
Weighted degradation 0 min 7 min 7 min 0 min 0 min 0 min
Pool
Unique IPs 2.47M 7.15M 7.15M 4.19M 8.95M 8.95M
Countries 212 216 216 221 221 221
Regions 2.5K 2.6K 2.6K 2.7K 2.8K 2.8K
Cities 64K 82K 82K 85K 104K 104K
ASNs 16K 18K 18K 22K 25K 25K
Trust
DC ASN share 0.75% 0.71% 0.71% 0.57% 0.56% 0.56%
Exclusive IPs 479K 393K 393K 1.66M 2.61M 2.61M
Likely upstream None found Shifter Shifter None found None found None found
Peer consent disclosed No No No Yes Yes Yes
Cost
$ / GB $1.85 $1.85 $1.85 $0.75 $0.75 $0.75
Cost per 1,000 successes $9.07 $9.07 $9.07 $4.43 $4.43 $4.43
Trial Free trial Free trial Free trial 50 MB Start trial Money-back Money-back Money-back 3 days Order now

Best third of all networks Middle third Bottom third Not measured yet

Next · 03 By target Which works better on the sites you use?
03 · By target

FleetProxy vs Shifter on each target

An overall score can hide a weak site, so whether you need FleetProxy for city or ISP-level work or Shifter for targeting-led work, look up your targets here.

FleetProxy Shifter
  1. 3.6/10 HTTP 4.2/10
  2. 3.6/10 HTTPS 4.2/10
  3. 9.4/10 Marketplace Not measured
  4. 5.5/10 Search 9.4/10
  5. Not measured Profile 1.6/10
  6. 4.1/10 Social 7.2/10
  7. 10.0/10 Challenge 8.7/10
  8. 1.0/10 AI 4.7/10
  1. 3.6/10 HTTP 7.9/10
  2. 2.1/10 HTTPS 7.4/10
  3. 9.5/10 Marketplace 5.2/10
  4. 5.2/10 Search 10.0/10
  5. 6.3/10 Profile 1.5/10
  6. 2.6/10 Social 4.2/10
  7. 10.0/10 Challenge 8.7/10
  8. 1.5/10 AI 6.3/10
  1. 3.6/10 HTTP 7.9/10
  2. 2.1/10 HTTPS 7.4/10
  3. 9.5/10 Marketplace 5.2/10
  4. 5.2/10 Search 10.0/10
  5. 6.3/10 Profile 1.5/10
  6. 2.6/10 Social 4.2/10
  7. 10.0/10 Challenge 8.7/10
  8. 1.5/10 AI 6.3/10

What each target tests, and why it is hard: the target suite

Next · 04 Price Which is cheaper, FleetProxy or Shifter?
04 · Price

What FleetProxy and Shifter really cost

FleetProxy offers per-GB plans with ASN filters and Shifter offers three pools priced by targeting; the cost per successful request below puts both on one scale.

FleetProxy logo FleetProxy

  • Rate card

    $1.59 to $2.65

    per GB

  • $ / 1k successes

    $9.07

    $9.07

    $9.07

  • Trial

    Free trial

    50 MB

Shifter logo Shifter

  • Rate card

    $0.75 to $2.00

    per GB

  • $ / 1k successes

    $4.43

    $4.43

    $4.43

  • Trial

    Money-back

    3 days

The bill for successful requests

What FleetProxy and Shifter bill for a fixed number of successful requests
Successful requests FleetProxyShifter
10,000 $91$44
100,000 $907$443
1,000,000 $9,068$4,429
10,000,000 $90,681$44,295
10,000 $91$44
100,000 $907$443
1,000,000 $9,068$4,429
10,000,000 $90,681$44,295
10,000 $91$44
100,000 $907$443
1,000,000 $9,068$4,429
10,000,000 $90,681$44,295
Successful requests only, for the target and time window picked, at each network's 200 GB plan price, retries included. A minimum monthly spend is not added: see the network's page.

Every measured network priced the same way: the true cost of residential proxies

Next · 05 IP pool Which has the better IP pool?
05 · IP pool

The exits of FleetProxy and Shifter

FleetProxy targets down to the city and the ASN and Shifter sells city-level and worldwide pools apart; here is what the measured pools hold and how many IPs they share.

FleetProxy Shifter
  1. 2.47M Unique IPs 4.19M
  2. 212 Countries 221
  3. 64K Cities 85K
  4. 16K ASNs 22K
  5. 0.7% Datacenter ASN share 0.6%
  1. 7.15M Unique IPs 8.95M
  2. 216 Countries 221
  3. 82K Cities 104K
  4. 18K ASNs 25K
  5. 0.7% Datacenter ASN share 0.6%
  1. 7.15M Unique IPs 8.95M
  2. 216 Countries 221
  3. 82K Cities 104K
  4. 18K ASNs 25K
  5. 0.7% Datacenter ASN share 0.6%

IPs seen on both FleetProxy and Shifter

941K

IPs seen on both pools in this window.

38.1% of the IPs seen on FleetProxy

27.7% of the IPs seen on Shifter

5.26M

IPs seen on both pools in this window.

73.5% of the IPs seen on FleetProxy

45.8% of the IPs seen on Shifter

5.26M

IPs seen on both pools in this window.

73.5% of the IPs seen on FleetProxy

45.8% of the IPs seen on Shifter

How pool overlap is measured

Shifter runs Atlas

This comparison includes Shifter, so it carries a conflict of interest. Shifter is tested on the same requests, targets and schedule as every other network, figures it has not published read Not measured rather than being filled in, and the dataset can be downloaded to check every number. Read the disclosure

Next · 06 Guide How do you choose between FleetProxy and Shifter?
06 · Guide

FleetProxy or Shifter: how to decide

What you want matters: often another mix of targeting and price for people moving off FleetProxy, one pool instead of a choice of three for people moving off Shifter.

Checklist

Where FleetProxy and Shifter can differ

Success on the sites you scrape

Success on the sites you use matters more than any average, whether you are among buyers who target by city or ISP looking at FleetProxy or teams that choose a pool by targeting looking at Shifter.

Cost per successful request

FleetProxy sells traffic with city and ASN filters, Shifter prices each of its three pools by targeting; to compare them fairly, count only successful requests in the cost, not the GB.

Unique IPs, not the advertised pool

FleetProxy is a provider centred on ASN filters and Shifter is the network that opened the category, but advertised pool sizes are claims; the distinct IPs Atlas saw are what you can count on.

How residential each pool is

Residential exits matter for FleetProxy, which is built around city and ASN targeting, as much as for Shifter, which is built around three dedicated pools, since sites block hosting ranges.

Coverage where you need it

Check the markets you need on FleetProxy, which targets down to the city and the ASN, and on Shifter, which sells city-level and worldwide pools apart, down to the cities and ASNs you target.

How the IPs are sourced

FleetProxy is one of the newest names around and Shifter is the original residential proxy network; whichever you choose, ask how each sources its IPs, and see the consent disclosure in the side by side table.

Related reading: What to test in a proxy free trial

FleetProxy vs Shifter: the method

Same requests, same targets

Being one of the newest names around or the original residential proxy network changes nothing here: FleetProxy and Shifter were sent the same requests, to the same targets, at the same times.

Read the full methodology, or download the dataset.

  • Same requests to the same targets
  • Same schedule and measurement window
  • Published formula for the Atlas Score
  • Gaps shown as Not measured, never filled

Run your own FleetProxy vs Shifter test

Run your targets through both, as FleetProxy starts with a city or ASN choice and Shifter starts with choosing a pool, then price by successful requests and move in stages. What to test in a proxy free trial

FAQ

Frequently asked questions

The questions people ask before settling on FleetProxy for its ASN-targeting offer or Shifter for its three-pool offer.

Shifter has the higher Atlas Score, 94.1 to 80.6. Of the 16 figures Atlas measured for both networks, FleetProxy takes 1 and Shifter takes 15, so check the rows that matter to you.

Shifter costs less per result: $4.43 per 1,000 successful requests against $9.07, counting failed requests.

Shifter is faster, with a median latency of 486 ms against 919 ms.

Across every target tested, Shifter scores 9.4/10 on success against 6.8/10.

Shifter handed out more distinct IPs: 8,948,662 against 7,150,983.

5,259,246 IPs were seen on both networks, so part of their pools overlaps.

Think of FleetProxy as a city and ASN network and Shifter as the first residential proxy network: FleetProxy is built around city and ASN targeting, Shifter is built around three dedicated pools. The tables show the gaps for buyers who target by city or ISP and teams that choose a pool by targeting.

You can, and code rarely changes, though pricing does, as Shifter prices each of its three pools by targeting and FleetProxy sells traffic with city and ASN filters. Before moving, compare the accuracy of ASN filters on your sites with the pool that matches your targeting and check the shared IPs on this page.

Get started

Test both on your own targets

Run a slice of your own traffic through FleetProxy and Shifter, checking the accuracy of ASN filters on your sites and the pool that matches your targeting, and keep the one that fits.

3-day money-back guarantee. Cancel anytime.