“Proxy or VPN?” sounds like a choice between two versions of the same thing. It isn’t. A VPN is a privacy tool for your whole connection. A proxy changes the IP address that websites see, for the apps you choose. They hide different things from different people, and websites treat their IP addresses very differently, which we measured below.
We sell residential proxies, not VPNs, so we have a side. This guide tries to be fair about when each one is the right tool, including when you need a VPN and not us.
The short answer
| VPN | Proxy | |
|---|---|---|
| What it covers | All traffic on the device | Only apps set to use it |
| Encryption | Encrypts everything to the VPN server | Adds none; HTTPS stays encrypted |
| Who sees your browsing | The VPN provider, not your ISP | Your ISP sees you connect to the proxy; the proxy sees the sites |
| IP websites see | Usually a data centre IP | Depends on the proxy: data centre, ISP or residential |
| Typical use | Privacy on untrusted networks | Location-specific access, testing, data collection |
| Several IPs at once | Rarely | Yes, by design |
What a VPN does
A VPN builds an encrypted tunnel from your device to the provider’s server, and all your traffic leaves from there. Your internet provider, or the café Wi-Fi, sees only that you are connected to a VPN.
The privacy moves, it does not disappear. As the EFF puts it, “while a VPN hides your browsing data from the ISP, it’s all visible to the VPN provider.” And it is clear about the limits: “A VPN is not a tool for anonymity.” Cookies, logins and browser fingerprints still identify you.
VPNs are mainstream. In an August 2026 survey by Security.org, a site that reviews VPNs, 42% of American adults said they used one, up from 32% in 2025.
What a proxy does
A proxy forwards the requests of the apps that use it, and websites see the proxy’s IP address instead of yours. It does not wrap your connection in a new layer of encryption. For HTTPS sites, which are now almost all of the web, the content stays encrypted between your browser and the site; the proxy passes it along without reading it.
Two details matter more than people expect:
- Scope. Only configured apps use the proxy. Your browser can go through it while everything else on the computer connects directly.
- DNS. Whether site names are looked up by the proxy or by your own network depends on the setup. With SOCKS5, for example, curl only lets the proxy resolve names when you ask it to. Our guide to DNS leaks shows how to check.
How websites see each one: our test
The biggest practical difference is the IP address itself. On 16 November 2026 we classified two sets of addresses with our IP Info service:
- 530 VPN servers: every active WireGuard server in the public server list of Mullvad, a well-known VPN provider.
- 99 residential proxy exits: 10 requests in each of 10 countries through our own gateway.
| VPN servers | Residential proxy exits | |
|---|---|---|
| Classified as hosting | 475 (90%) | 0 |
| Networks they came from | 27 | 61 |
| Typical networks | Hosting providers | Deutsche Telekom, BT, Orange, Free, Comcast |
| In the requested country | n/a | 99 of 99 |
The VPN result is not a quirk of one provider. Mullvad says plainly that “VPN services such as Mullvad rent or lease servers from data centers all over the world.” A data centre address shared by many users is easy to spot, which is why streaming services show messages like Netflix’s: “You seem to be using a VPN or proxy.”
Residential proxy IPs come from home and business internet connections, so they look like ordinary visitors. Our guide to IP reputation explains how sites score addresses.
Who can see what
| Who | With a VPN | With a proxy |
|---|---|---|
| Your ISP or Wi-Fi owner | That you use a VPN | That you use a proxy, and what non-proxied apps do |
| The website | The VPN’s IP | The proxy’s IP |
| The provider | All your traffic metadata | The sites your proxied apps visit |
| Trackers in the browser | Everything they saw before | Everything they saw before |
The last row is the one people forget. Neither tool clears cookies, logs you out or changes your browser fingerprint. Your browser can also reveal your real address through WebRTC, which our guide to WebRTC leaks covers.
Is public Wi-Fi still a reason for a VPN?
Less than it was. Google says the share of Chrome navigations over HTTPS rose from around 30-45% in 2015 to “the 95-99% range around 2020”, so the content of most pages is already encrypted on any network. What HTTPS does not hide is metadata: in the EFF’s words, “HTTPS only protects the content of your communications, not the metadata.” On a network you do not trust, a VPN still hides which sites you visit from the people running it.
When to use which
Use a VPN when you want privacy for everything on a device: on public Wi-Fi, when you do not want your ISP to see your browsing, or when you want one simple switch for the whole computer.
Use a proxy when you need a specific IP for specific work: seeing a site as a visitor in another country, checking ads or prices by market, testing localized pages, or running many sessions with different IPs. Residential proxies matter here because sites treat them as normal visitors.
Use neither when you need anonymity. Our piece on why a proxy is not an anonymity tool explains what actually identifies people online, and Tor is built for that job.
The bottom line
A VPN protects your connection; a proxy changes your address for the apps that use it. If you want privacy from your network, use a VPN. If you need websites to see a particular kind of IP in a particular place, use a proxy, and a residential one if the site cares whether you look like a real visitor. In our test, nine in ten VPN server addresses were classified as data centre hosting; none of our residential exits were.
Sources and references
- EFF Surveillance Self-Defense, Choosing the VPN that’s right for you (last reviewed 28 July 2026): ssd.eff.org
- NIST glossary, proxy server and virtual private network: csrc.nist.gov, csrc.nist.gov
- Security.org, VPN consumer report 2026: security.org
- curl manual, SOCKS options: curl.se
- Mullvad, public server list API: api.mullvad.net
- Mullvad, multihop and data centre servers: mullvad.net
- Netflix Help Center, VPN or proxy error: help.netflix.com
- Google, HTTPS by default (28 October 2025): blog.google
- Shifter IP Info, the IP classification used in our test: ip-info.com